All-Time Records
| Played | Won | Drawn | Lost | Scored | Conceded | Goal Diff |
| 496 | 297 (59.9%) |
66 (13.3%) |
133 (26.8%) |
1284 (2.59 pg) |
723 (1.46 pg) |
+561 |
| Top Scorers |
 |
Graeme Rodger (84 goals) |
| Garry Wood (83 goals) |
| Cammy Keith (72 goals) |
| Scott Barbour (68 goals) |
| Archie MacPhee (59 goals) |
| Conor Gethins (52 goals) |
| Neil Gauld (41 goals) |
| Stuart Anderson (34 goals) |
| Barry Somers (30 goals) |
| Andrew Greig (30 goals) |
| Most Appearances |
 |
Stuart Smith (279 appearances) |
| Graeme Rodger (250 apps) |
| Stuart Anderson (240 apps) |
| Johnny Crawford (179 apps) |
| Garry Wood (178 apps) |
| Craig McKeown (155 apps) |
| Conor Gethins (147 apps) |
| Calum Dingwall (137 apps) |
| Scott Barbour (131 apps) |
| Andrew Greig (111 apps) |
| Biggest Win |
|
Formartine United 14 - 1 Fort William
Jan 5th, 2019 |
| Biggest League Win |
|
Formartine United 14 - 1 Fort William
Jan 5th, 2019 |
| Heaviest Defeat |
|
Deveronvale 7 - 1 Formartine United
Feb 23rd, 2011 |
| Most Goals In A Game |
|
Neil Gauld - 8 goals
Apr 16th, 2016 |
| Most Goals In A Season |
|
Archie MacPhee - 33 goals (2017-18)
0.77 goals per game |
| Most League Goals In A Season |
|
Barry Somers - 28 goals (2009-10)
0.82 goals per game |
| Highest Transfer Fee Paid |
|
Trialist Trialist - £0 |